Skip to content

Flat-rate worldwide shipping — $13 USD under 2KG/Hassle-free returns & exchanges/Tracking on every order

Kit Guide

What Goes Under Training Kit, and When the Answer Is Nothing

The layer nobody writes about, sitting where sweat collects most and friction is highest. It is also the layer most people are still wearing cotton in.

6 min read  /  Updated 15 August 2026  /  MuscleDog USA editorial team

Black boxer briefs shown flat
The base layer under everything else, and the one most often overlooked.

Two questions cover it. Does the garment over the top already have a liner, and if not, what should the layer underneath be made of?

01

Liner or no liner

Many running and training shorts include a built-in brief. It is designed to be worn against skin, and wearing underwear beneath it adds a seam and a damp layer that the liner was meant to replace.

SetupLayers against skinChafe riskDrying
Lined short, nothing underOneLowestFast
Lined short plus underwearTwoHigherSlowest
Unlined short plus fitted syntheticOneLowFast
Unlined short plus cottonOne, absorbentHighestSlowest
Unlined short, nothingNoneHigh skin-on-skinFast
What each combination gives you

The second row is the common mistake. If the short has a liner, the liner is the underwear, and doubling up creates exactly the friction it was designed to remove.

If it has a liner, the liner is the underwear.

Doubling up recreates the problem the liner solves
02

Fabric, and why cotton is wrong here too

This layer sits where sweat collects most and stays there longest. Everything the rest of the site says about cotton applies with more force.

FabricMoistureDry timeOdourVerdict
CottonAbsorbs and holdsSlowestLowNot for training
Polyester blendWicksFastBuildsGood
Nylon blendWicksFastestBuildsBest for running
Modal or bambooAbsorbs somewhatModerateLowComfortable, slower
Merino blendAbsorbs, stays dry-feelingSlowVery lowBest for long days
Fabrics for the base layer

Merino is worth knowing about for anyone training and then going straight to work: it holds odour far less than synthetics, which is the practical difference over a long day. Fibre behaviour generally is in our workout t-shirt fabric guide.

03

Cut, and what each one is actually for

CutCoverageRides upBest for
Boxer brief, long legMid-thighRarelyLifting, most training
Boxer brief, short legUpper thighSometimesGeneral wear
BriefMinimalNoHot weather, minimal bulk
Loose boxerMid-thigh, unfittedConstantlyNot for training
Compression shortMid-thigh, tightNoRunning, contact sport
Cuts compared

Loose boxers are the one genuinely poor choice. The fabric moves independently of both you and the short, which is the definition of a friction problem. Our chafing guide covers why.

Legs in a compression layer, black and white
A fitted layer moves with you. A loose one moves against you.
04

The waistband is where it fails

Two waistbands stacked at the same height is uncomfortable and is what most people are actually feeling when they say a short does not fit.

  • Offset the heights — the under layer lower or higher.
  • Avoid two gripper strips at the same point on the skin.
  • Flat, wide bands distribute pressure; thin ones dig in.
  • Check under a belt if you lift with one.

Waistband construction in the outer short is covered in our gym shorts length guide.

05

Heat, humidity and skin

This is the least ventilated area of your kit. Damp fabric held against skin for an hour is the same mechanism behind breakouts elsewhere.

Occlusion, warmth and time are what cause the problem, and the fix is the same: get out of damp kit quickly rather than choosing a different product. Our guide to gym skin irritation covers the mechanism, and general urologic health information is published by NIDDK, part of the National Institutes of Health.

Macro detail of a soft grey knit
The least ventilated layer in the kit, and the wettest.
06

By activity

ActivityRecommendedAvoid
LiftingLong-leg boxer brief, syntheticLoose boxers
Running, lined shortsNothingAnything, including briefs
Running, unlined shortsCompression short or fitted briefCotton
Classes and HIITFitted syntheticLoose anything
CyclingPadded short, nothing underSeamed underwear
Long day after trainingMerino blendPolyester
What to wear under what
A figure in a locker room doorway, black and white
The gap between finishing and changing matters here most of all.
07

How many, and how long they last

This is the item people under-buy and over-keep. It takes the heaviest sweat load per square inch of anything you own.

SignMeaning
Waistband no longer gripsElastane gone — replace
Fabric thin at the seatStructural — replace
Odour survives a proper washOils set in the fibre — replace
Seams puckeringNearly finished
Still fits and smells cleanKeep
Replacement signals

One pair per training session between washes is the realistic minimum, on the same logic as the rest of the wardrobe — see our guide to how many gym clothes you need.

08

Washing this layer properly

Same rules as everything else, with less tolerance for shortcuts because the oil load is higher.

  1. Wash inside out, cool, with an enzyme detergent.
  2. Never fabric softener — it seals oils into the fibre.
  3. Air dry; heat destroys the waistband first.
  4. Wash within a day, not at the end of the week.
  5. If odour persists after a proper wash, retire it.

Why synthetics hold odour, and how to strip it, is in our gym clothes care guide.

A plain laundry basket
Higher oil load than anything else you own, and washed the least carefully.
09

Seams are the detail that decides comfort

More than fabric, and more than cut. This layer has seams running through the exact areas that move most and sweat most.

ConstructionFeelChafe riskTypical price point
Bonded or seamlessAlmost nothingLowestPremium
FlatlockFlat ridgeLowMid
OverlockRaisedModerateBudget
Centre seam at the gussetNoticeableHighestAny
Seam construction in base layers

A centre seam running through the gusset is the one to avoid outright, regardless of what the fabric is. A pouch construction with the seams offset to the sides is more comfortable at any price.

One practical note on buying: this is a category where trying a single pair before committing to a multipack genuinely pays. Cut and rise vary far more between makers than the size label suggests, and a five-pack of the wrong shape is an expensive way to learn that.

The same applies to fit across brands: a medium in one maker sits an inch higher on the leg than a medium in another, and the leg length is what decides whether it rides up during a session.

10

The short version

  1. Lined shorts need nothing underneath.
  2. Unlined shorts want a fitted synthetic layer.
  3. Never cotton, and never loose boxers.
  4. Offset the waistbands so they do not stack.
  5. Replace when the waistband stops gripping.
Folded garments in an open drawer
One pair per session between washes is the realistic floor.

Frequently asked questions

Should you wear underwear under lined running shorts?

No. The built-in liner is designed to sit against skin and is doing the job underwear would do. Adding a layer beneath it introduces an extra seam and a second damp layer, which recreates exactly the friction the liner exists to prevent.

What underwear is best for the gym?

A fitted synthetic boxer brief with a long leg for lifting, or a compression short for running in unlined shorts. The key features are that it moves with you rather than against you, and that it wicks rather than absorbs. Loose boxers are the worst option.

Is cotton underwear bad for working out?

Yes, for the same reason cotton is a poor choice everywhere else in training kit, only more so. This layer sits where sweat collects most and stays damp longest. Cotton absorbs and holds that moisture, which softens skin and raises friction.

Why do two waistbands feel uncomfortable?

Because they stack at the same point on the skin and double the pressure there. Offsetting the heights so the under layer sits slightly higher or lower solves it, as does avoiding two silicone gripper strips at the same level.

How often should you replace training underwear?

When the waistband stops gripping with the garment otherwise intact, when the fabric has thinned at the seat, or when odour survives a proper enzyme wash. This item takes the heaviest sweat load per square inch of anything in the wardrobe and is usually kept far longer than it should be.